when is revolution a proper course for action

by Eloisa Hansen 8 min read

What do you mean by Revolution?

English Language Learners Definition of revolution : the usually violent attempt by many people to end the rule of one government and start a new one : a sudden, extreme, or complete change in the way people live, work, etc. : the action of moving around something in a path that is similar to a circle : rotation

What is the right of revolution?

] In political philosophy, the right of revolution (or right of rebellion) is the right or duty of the people of a nation to overthrow a government that acts against their common interests and/or threatens the safety of the people without cause.

What can we learn from Revolution?

The topic of revolution presents a fertile and challenging field for moral theory and applied or practical ethics—and one in which the greater part of systematic thinking remains to be done. Violent revolutions typically present the most serious and difficult moral issues.

What is a “course of action”?

This course of action is what the Constitution envisions and also slows down the hasty rush to war. With any course of action there is a desired or anticipated outcome. This all indicates that this is more than a normal course of action , a situational event.

What is revolution in science?

When did revolutions start?

How long does it take for the Earth to make one revolution?

How long does it take for the Earth to revolution around the Sun?

What does "revolt" mean?

See 2 more

About this website

What was the primary goal of the American Revolution?

The principal goal of the American Revolution was liberty from England. The French Revolution's goal was liberty, equality, and fraternity. Define natural rights.

When in the Course of human events it becomes necessary meaning?

Notice the words that Jefferson used in the opening. He wrote, "It becomes necessary." By using these words, Jefferson was saying that there was only one way to proceed — through war.

What other efforts did Jefferson claim that the colonists made quizlet?

What rights does Jefferson claim that the colonies now possess? They have full Power to levy War, conclude Peace, contract Alliances, establish Commerce, and to do all other Acts and Things which Independent States may of right do.

What was the core idea expressed in the Declaration of Independence?

The Declaration of Independence included these three major ideas: People have certain Inalienable Rights including Life, Liberty and Pursuit of Happiness. All Men are created equal. Individuals have a civic duty to defend these rights for themselves and others.

What is the right to overthrow government?

In political philosophy, the right of revolution (or right of rebellion) is the right or duty of a people to "alter or abolish" a government that acts against their common interests or threatens the safety of the people without cause.

What is Jefferson saying here about overthrowing the government?

Overthrowing a government is not a decision to be taken lightly. People should not overthrow their government for just any reason. According to Jefferson, when does it become "necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another"?

Who was responsible for the abuses to the colonists?

Summary. The colonies have suffered 27 at the hands of the King George III. Each of these abuses has been directed at the colonies for the purpose of establishing a tyrannical government in North America.

On what did Jefferson base his belief that all men are created equal?

What he really meant was that the American colonists, as a people, had the same rights of self-government as other peoples, and hence could declare independence, create new governments and assume their “separate and equal station” among other nations.

What were the three purposes of the Declaration of Independence?

Its goals were to rally the troops, win foreign allies, and to announce the creation of a new country. The introductory sentence states the Declaration's main purpose, to explain the colonists' right to revolution.

How effectively does the Declaration justify rebellion?

The Declaration of Independence justified our right to revolt against a government that no longer guaranteed us our natural rights. And it also helped us to get increased foreign assistance from France in our fight to become free from King George III of England.

Which best describes the main action called for by the Declaration of Independence?

Which best describes the main action called for by the Declaration of Independence? Why were taxes an ongoing source of conflict for the American colonists? They were taxed without having representation in Parliament. The Declaration of Independence refers to rights as being unalienable.

Why is the Declaration of Independence so important?

The importance of the Declaration of Independence can hardly be overstated. It established for the first time in world history a new nation based on the First Principles of the rule of law, unalienable rights, limited government, the Social Compact, equality, and the right to alter or abolish oppressive government.

When in the Course of human events it becomes necessary for one person?

The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America, When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and ...

What starts with When in the Course of human events?

Preamble: the reasons for writing down the Declaration (from "WHEN, in the Course of human Events" to "declare the Causes which impel them to the Separation."). What reason(s) did the Founding Fathers give for their decision to write out a declaration?

What words does Jefferson use in the opening of the second paragraph that means obvious?

What word does Jefferson use in opening of the second paragraph that means "obvious"? Who institutes, or creates government? What basic rights do all men have? Life, Liberty, and the persuit of happiness.

What does political bands mean in the Declaration of Independence?

What Jefferson means that, the U.S. should separate from Great Britain and become one country. 2. What are "political bands" in reference to Jefferson's statement? In this statement, the political bands are the colonists, and Great Britain.

Revolution Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com

Revolution definition, an overthrow or repudiation and the thorough replacement of an established government or political system by the people governed. See more.

REVOLUTION | meaning, definition in Cambridge English Dictionary

revolution definition: 1. a change in the way a country is governed, usually to a different political system and often…. Learn more.

What is revolution in science?

1 a (1) : the action by a celestial body of going round in an orbit or elliptical course also : apparent movement of such a body round the earth. (2) : the time taken by a celestial body to make a complete round in its orbit. (3) : the rotation of a celestial body on its axis. b : completion of a course (as of years) ...

When did revolutions start?

When revolution first appeared in English in the 14th century, it referred to the movement of a celestial body in orbit; that sense was extended to “a progressive motion of a body around an axis,” “completion of a course,” and other senses suggesting regularity of motion or a predictable return to an original position.

How long does it take for the Earth to make one revolution?

3 : a single complete turn (as of a wheel) The earth makes one revolution on its axis in 24 hours.

How long does it take for the Earth to revolution around the Sun?

the revolution of the Earth around the Sun The period of revolution of the Earth around the Sun is equal to one year. The Earth makes one revolution on its axis in about 24 hours. This motor operates at a speed of 5,000 revolutions per minute. See More.

What does "revolt" mean?

rebellion, revolution, uprising, revolt, insurrection, mutiny mean an outbreak against authority. rebellion implies an open formidable resistance that is often unsuccessful. open rebellion against the officers revolution applies to a successful rebellion resulting in a major change (as in government). a political revolution that toppled the monarchy uprising implies a brief, limited, and often immediately ineffective rebellion. quickly put down the uprising revolt and insurrection imply an armed uprising that quickly fails or succeeds. a revolt by the Young Turks that surprised party leaders an insurrection of oppressed laborers mutiny applies to group insubordination or insurrection especially against naval authority. a mutiny led by the ship's cook

When do agents have the rightful authority to try to initiate a revolutionary war?

An initially plausible answer is that the agent must stand in a certain relationship to the people on whose behalf the revolutionary war is to be waged. Different theorists have tried to spell out this relationship in different ways, asserting that the initiator of revolutionary war (i) must have the consent of those on whose behalf she claims to act, (ii) must have their approval, (iii) must represent them, or (iv) must take responsibility for their common good (and have the capacity to pursue it effectively). Each of these proposals will be considered in turn. The distinction between consent and approval is to be understood as follows: consent must be provided ex ante, prior to the action to which consent is given; approval is ex post, a retrospective endorsement of an action that has already occurred.

Why is violent revolution important?

Because violent revolution poses the most serious and difficult moral issues, it will be the focus of the remainder of the entry. The morality of nonviolent resistance to political authority is itself sufficiently distinctive, significant and complex to warrant a separate entry.

What is the second argument in the case of the Revolutionary War?

The second is the conviction that the requirement of rightful authority cannot, as a matter of logical necessity, be met in the case of revolutionary war (The Conceptual Argument). Consider first the Undue Risk Argument for the conclusion that revolution is never or only rarely justified.

What is the view that rejects revolution?

The first is an overriding aversion to the perceived risk of violent anarchy posed by attempts to overth row a government (the Undue Risk Argument). The second is the conviction that the requirement of rightful authority cannot, as a matter of logical necessity, be met in the case of revolutionary war (The Conceptual Argument).

What are the moral issues of revolution?

The moral issues posed by revolutions are both practically important and theoretically complex. There are also interesting conceptual questions as to how to distinguish revolution from resistance, rebellion, and secession, all of which also involve opposition to existing political authority. Unfortunately, the recent renaissance in just war theorizing focuses implicitly on interstate wars and thus has largely ignored the morality of revolution, at least as a topic worthy of systematic theorizing in its own right. [ 1] Recent work on the morality of asymmetrical warfare, on terrorism, and on humanitarian military intervention provides valuable resources for constructing a theory of the morality of revolution, but until the appearance of Christopher Finlay’s book, Terrorism and the Right to Resist: A Theory of Just Revolutionary War (2015), nothing approaching a systematic account of the morality of revolution has been available. [ 2] In other words, moral theorizing relevant to revolution has been rather fragmentary and adventitious, because it has mainly occurred in the pursuit of other topics rather than as part of an inquiry directed squarely at the phenomenon of revolution. Furthermore, although prominent figures in the history of Philosophy have held views on revolution, they have primarily concentrated on the issue of just cause (and in some cases on rightful authority to wage revolutionary war), without addressing a number of other moral problems that revolutions raise, such as the question of whether revolutionaries can rightly use forms of violence that the armed forces of states are morally prohibited from using and whether they may conscript fighters, punish defectors and traitors, and expropriate property needed for the struggle. There are hopeful signs, however, that moral theorists will soon give revolution the attention it deserves.

Why did Locke take a more favorable stance toward revolution than Hobbes or his medieval predecessors?

Locke took a more favorable stance toward revolution than Hobbes or his medieval predecessors, because he did not believe that the risks of physical insecurity attendant upon the destruction of an existing government were as high as those thinkers did.

What is the conclusion of the study of the Revolutionary War?

The Conclusion emphasizes some of the major results of the investigation and suggests two further topics that a comprehensive theory of just revolutionary war should address: the morality of intervention in revolution and how it is shaped by the morality of revolution; and the moral assessment of the international Law of Armed Conflict’s asymmetric treatment of the rights of combatants fighting on behalf of states and revolutionary fighters.

What is the right of revolution?

In political philosophy, the right of revolution (or right of rebellion) is the right or duty of a people to overthrow a government that acts against their common interests and/or threatens the safety of the people without cause. Stated throughout history in one form or another, the belief in this right has been used ...

How was the right of revolution justified?

As explained in legal historian Christian Fritz's description of the role of the right of revolution in American Revolution, American independence was justified by conventional theories under Anglo-American constitutional thought at the time about the people's collective right to cast off an arbitrary king. "Both natural law and English constitutional doctrine gave the colonists a right to revolt against the sovereign's oppression." But these understandings about the right of revolution on the eve of the American Revolution rested on a traditional model of government. That model posited the existence of a hypothetical bargain struck in the mists of antiquity between a king and a people. "In this bargain, the people were protected by the monarch in exchange for the people giving the king allegiance. This was a contractual relationship. American revolutionaries accused George III of breaching his implied duty of protection under that contract, thereby releasing the people in the colonies from their allegiance. The sovereign's breach of the hypothetical contract gave rise to the subjects' right of revolution—grounded on both natural law and English constitutional doctrine."

Why is it important to rebel?

Howard Evans Kiefer opines, "It seems to me that the duty to rebel is much more understandable than that right to rebel, because the right to rebellion ruins the order of power, whereas the duty to rebel goes beyond and breaks it."

What did Chinese historians believe was the result of a successful revolt?

Chinese historians interpreted a successful revolt as evidence that the Mandate of Heaven had passed on. Throughout Chinese history, rebels who opposed the ruling dynasty made the claim that the Mandate of Heaven had passed, giving them the right to revolt.

Why was the right to revolt cited in the year prior to the Civil War?

The inherent (rather than constitutional) right to revolt was cited in the year prior the civil war's start as justifying the secession of the Confederate States of America.

When the ends of government are perverted, and public liberty manifestly endangered, and all other means of redress?

Whenever the ends of government are perverted, and public liberty manifestly endangered, and all other means of redress are ineffectual, the people may, and of right ought to reform the old, or establish a new government. The doctrine of nonresistance against arbitrary power, and oppression, is absurd, slavish, and destructive of the good and happiness of mankind.

When was the right of revolution included in the French Constitution?

The right of revolution was also included in the 1793 preface to the French Constitution of 1793 during the French Revolution. This preface from 24 June 1793 contained a declaration of the rights of man and citizen including right to rebellion in §35: "When the government violates the rights of the people, insurrection is for the people, and for every portion thereof, the most sacred of rights and the most indispensable of duties."

What is the Unfinished Revolution?

The Civil War and Reconstruction – 1865-1890: The Unfinished Revolution is a free online history course offered by Columbia University in the United States. Students have the option to take the course alone or as a part of the Civil War and Reconstruction XSeries program offered by the university. Entirely self-paced, the class can be completed at a rate that is comfortable for the student. The instructor does suggest that students break the class down into 15 weekly units, spending about six to eight hours on the coursework each week. Through is class, students will learn about the causes of the Civil War, the impact of the fighting and the reconstruction process. The class ends with an examination of how unresolved issues from the Civil War continue to affect the United States today.

How long is the French Revolution?

Although the class is self-paced, the instructor recommends that students complete one of the course’s video modules each week. The six-week course will require a weekly time commitment of six to seven hours. Open to anyone with an interest in European history, the class has no educational prerequisites or work experience requirements. The course is comprised of six units: France in the 1780s; The Revolution of 1789; The Reconstruction of France, 1789-92; The Republic in Crisis 1792-93; Ending the Terror and Ending the Revolution; and Change and Continuity: How Revolutionary Was the Revolution?

What is the class "From Freedom Rides to Ferguson"?

From Freedom Rides to Ferguson: Narratives of Nonviolence in the American Civil Rights Movement is a free online human rights course offered by Emory University in the United States. The five-week class is presented through online video lectures from Emory University professors and guest speakers that include Andrew Young, Reverend C.T. Vivian, Henry “Hank” Thomas and Constance Curry. The five one-week units that make up the class are: Movements & Campaigns; Organizations of the Civil Rights Movement; Nonviolent Philosophies & Tactics; Organizational & Social Change; and Education for Change and the Future of Nonviolence Conflict Transformation.

What is human rights activism?

Human Rights Activism, Advocacy and Change is a free online humanities course offered by Curtin University in Australia. The course can be taken independently or as a part of the Human Rights Micro Masters program offered by the university. Presented through online videos, assignments and readings, the class involves a time commitment of eight to 10 hours per week. The course lasts for 12 weeks with students completing one unit weekly. Some of the topics explored in the class include: Social Movements and Power; Women’s Rights and Activism: Unity and Difference; Mahatma Gandhi: Satyagraha, Satya and Ahimsa; Women and Nonviolence Movements; Saul Alinsky: Citizen Participation and Organisation; Frantz Fanon and Decolonisation; Queer (y)ing Human Rights Activism; Indigenous Protest and Activism; Disability Rights and Activism; and Refugee Rights And Activism.

What is the course after the Arab Spring?

After the Arab Spring – Democratic Aspirations and State Failure is a free online political science course offered by the University of Copenhagen in Denmark. The class is open to anyone who is interested in learning more about the outcomes of the Arab spring uprisings. Video lectures are used to present the course material. The course is broken down into six week-long units, each requiring two to three hours of study time to complete. At the start of the course, students learn about the instability and institutional failures that led to the Arab spring uprisings. Next, the class focuses on the challenges to the movements with the following modules: Governance; Institutions; Economics: Bread, Dignity and Freedom; and Human Development: Growth and Frustration. The final module, Outlook: Elusive Stability, provides predictions about the state of the Middle East going forward.

What is Amnesty International course?

Amnesty International offers a free course where participants learn about who human rights defenders are, what they have achieved so far, and how they overcome struggles. The creators of the course have prepared plenty of materials which give insights into hands-on experiences by both human rights defenders and their families. Essentially, this course is not only about honoring human rights defenders but also about learning how to become one.

What is revolution in science?

1 a (1) : the action by a celestial body of going round in an orbit or elliptical course also : apparent movement of such a body round the earth. (2) : the time taken by a celestial body to make a complete round in its orbit. (3) : the rotation of a celestial body on its axis. b : completion of a course (as of years) ...

When did revolutions start?

When revolution first appeared in English in the 14th century, it referred to the movement of a celestial body in orbit; that sense was extended to “a progressive motion of a body around an axis,” “completion of a course,” and other senses suggesting regularity of motion or a predictable return to an original position.

How long does it take for the Earth to make one revolution?

3 : a single complete turn (as of a wheel) The earth makes one revolution on its axis in 24 hours.

How long does it take for the Earth to revolution around the Sun?

the revolution of the Earth around the Sun The period of revolution of the Earth around the Sun is equal to one year. The Earth makes one revolution on its axis in about 24 hours. This motor operates at a speed of 5,000 revolutions per minute. See More.

What does "revolt" mean?

rebellion, revolution, uprising, revolt, insurrection, mutiny mean an outbreak against authority. rebellion implies an open formidable resistance that is often unsuccessful. open rebellion against the officers revolution applies to a successful rebellion resulting in a major change (as in government). a political revolution that toppled the monarchy uprising implies a brief, limited, and often immediately ineffective rebellion. quickly put down the uprising revolt and insurrection imply an armed uprising that quickly fails or succeeds. a revolt by the Young Turks that surprised party leaders an insurrection of oppressed laborers mutiny applies to group insubordination or insurrection especially against naval authority. a mutiny led by the ship's cook

image

Conceptual Matters

Some Major Figures’ Views on The Morality of Revolution

  • No attempt can be made here to conduct a survey of views on revolutionacross the history of Western Philosophy, much less one thatencompasses other traditions. Instead, it must suffice to say that thetypical attitude toward revolution of major figures in the Westerntradition prior to the modern period was to condemn it or toacknowledge its moral permissibility only in very narrow …
See more on plato.stanford.edu

Distinctive Features of Revolutionary Wars

  • A key question that will arise at a number of points in thisinvestigation is whether mainstream just war theory, in spite of itsimplicit focus on interstate wars provides an adequate account of themorality of revolutionary wars. To answer this question, there are atleast seven potentially morally significant differences to keep inmind. First, satisfaction of the traditional jus ad bellumr…
See more on plato.stanford.edu

Revolutionary Jus Ad Bellum, Revolutionary Jus in Bello

  • “The morality of making revolutionary war” is too broad atopic. It is necessary to factor out the distinctive moral problemsfaced by those who initiate revolutionary war and aspire to recruitand lead others in the struggle[8]and those who join the revolution once it is underway and do sowithout any pretensions to being leaders. These two classes of...
See more on plato.stanford.edu

Conclusion

  • The topic of revolution presents a fertile and challenging field formoral theory and applied or practical ethics—and one in whichthe greater part of systematic thinking remains to be done. Violentrevolutions typically present the most serious and difficult moralissues. Until recently, the excellent work done by contemporary justwar theories has not given the peculiar moral problem…
See more on plato.stanford.edu