why does haemon think creon should change course?

Summary Creon's son, Haemon, reasons with his father to change his mind and free Antigone in order to avoid offending those citizens who side with her. Creon rejects his son's advice fiercely and threatens to kill Antigone right in front of him.

Full Answer

What happens to Creon's son Haemon in Antigone?

Haemon's arguments to Creon do not fundamentally change over the course of their interaction. What does change is the bond between son and father. What does change is …

Why does Creon question Haemon's motives?

How does Haemon convince Creon? At first, Haemon flatters the absolutist king Creon by declaring his complete loyalty to him and by extension the state.Haemon relates the intelligence that the people of Thebes think the punishment is too much for a pious deed.

What is the difference between Creon and Haemon?

Dec 16, 2021 · Summary and Analysis: Antigone Lines 701-878. Creon’s son, Haemon, reasons with his father to change his mind and free Antigone in order to avoid offending those citizens who side with her. Creon rejects his son’s advice fiercely and threatens to kill Antigone right in front of him.

What does Haemon want his father to understand about him?

3.) Why does Haemon think Creon should change course? Creon is being incredibly selfish in his rule and Haemon straight up tells him that. 4.) Why does Creon finally change his mind? He figures out how close-minded he is being and decides to change his ways. The Chorus guides commentary, Sophocles wants Athenians to "reflect and learn". Creon and Antigone is a …

What is the main argument that Haemon uses in order to persuade Creon to change his mind?

What is the main argument that Haemon uses to persuade Creon to change his mind how does Creon respond? Haemon is saying that if Creon kills Antigone he will commit suicide and follow her tragic demise. Creon thinks that Haemon is implying that if he kills Antigone Haemon will kill him, his father.Dec 16, 2021

What comparison does Haemon make to explain why Creon should change his mind?

What comparison does Haimon make to explain why Creon should change his mind? He uses the metaphor of a train. He talks about the value of money.

How does Haemon change Creon's mind?

How does Haemon react when he hears the news of his father's order? he tries to convince him to change his mind by giving him info to be more open minded.

How does Haemon's attitude change over the course of his interaction with Creon?

6. How has Haemon's tone/attitude toward Creon changed from the beginning to end of scene 3? At the beginning, he was respectful and trying to flatter Creon. At the end he is desperate and accuses Creon of being too stubborn and of offending the gods.

How does Creon's speech to Haemon about obedience reflect his hubris?

how does antigone suggest that creon is a tyrant? ... how does creon's address to haemon about obedience reflect his hubris? he puts obedience over everything else. is haemon being sincere in his approval of his father's judgment?

What point does Haemon make about how King should rule?

In Scene 3 of Antigone, Part 2, Haimon argues with his father, King Creon. In that argument, what pioint does Haimon make about how a king should rule? A king should be ruled by the people, rather than the other way around.

How did Haemon persuade Creon?

How does Haemon try to persuade his father to change his position? Haemon reports that the citizens of Thebes feel that Creon's punishment is wrong. ... Creon believes that if he changes his min to satisfy his own son that the people of Thebes... Will think that he is too weak to even rule his own child.

What does Haemon say to Creon?

When Creon questions him about his loyalties, Haemon replies that no woman is as important as his father and that he will obey Creon. Pleased, the king praises his son's wisdom. Haemon reports that he has heard it said among the people that Antigone does not deserve such punishment for her noble-seeming deed.

What metaphors does Haemon use to convince his father to change his mind?

Haemon compares Creon to a tree that doesn't bend and gets torn up for being stubborn, and he also uses a metaphor on sailing. In a nutshell, he saying that stubborness will only lead to him breaking at one point.

Why do you think Haemon changes his attitude toward his father?

Scene 3: How has Haemon's attitude toward his father changed since the scene's opening? He began by trying to honor his father. He leaves in a fit of rage that his father is so tyrannical. Scene 3: How does Creon plan to free the State from any culpability in Antigone's death?

What do Creon and haemon argue about?

Creon believes that that king must always be obeyed, and that only people who obey can be honored and trusted. Haemon's argument: Haemon wants to save Antigone because he loves her, and he and others of the city believe that her crime should be forgiven.Sep 20, 2013

How does Haemon change throughout Antigone?

While the play still ends with Antigone's death, Haemon does end up changing his father's mind, even if it's too late. Unfortunately for Haemon, he takes his own life, unable to reconcile his conflict.Dec 7, 2021

What is the difference between Creon and Haemon?

The difference between Haemon and Creon is that Haemon is unable to support his claim by his authority as a ruler, and so he has to demonstrate the validity of his claim by readiness to die for it. Both opponents in this dispute feel that their personal authority is not enough to support their arguments.

What does Creon say about the law?

What Creon formally says is that the law must have its way and that Antigone has to be punished for disobedience. He further refers to the common good of the people as justification explaining that “what keeps their lives secure in almost every case is their obedience”.

How does Haemon argue against Creon?

Haemon appeals to his father's authority in the beginning, but as he continues to talk, he subtly points out some of Creon's faults--such as his being too prideful. Haemon argues against Creon's beliefs in an attempt to spare Antigone. The king's son lets out his rebellious side and says that it isn't one's age that matters, but one's actions. He shows his support for moral/divine law over human law, and in doing so, Haemon justifies Antigone's crime. His argument was not completely effective, though, as it only convinced Creon to give Antigone a harsher death.

How does Haemon appeal to Creon's authority?

Haemon appeals to Creon's authority by showing him respect when speaking to him. His logic that by stoning Antigone the people will think of her as a hero is valid. Creon even listens to this but instead of freeing Antigone as Haemon wants he decided that stoning is not the best way for her to die.

What is Creon's argument?

Creon’s argument is justified toward his reaction to Antigone’s “betrayal” and treatment of those in his presence. His points are all things that we’ve seen from him before, honoring the law above ones family and the submission expected from women. Adding his son and heir, you would think that he would accidentally contradict himself, but he doesn’t. Except for a few times, he doesn’t show any mercy toward his son nor Antigone. Creon argues that the law always comes before family, therefore saying that Antigone defied the law. Those things are purely wrong in his sight and speech. His argument is thorough, but it does not appeal to the audience/reader. Because he is depicted as the “bad guy” in the text, his argument is hardly relevant, but it is symbolic.