The sentence that is the most accurate summary of Dillon's rule is "Local governments only have the power that is specifically granted to them by states." Dillon's rule served as the foundation of the municipal law. It is used to interpret state law when there is a controversy on whether or not the local government has the power to do something.
Full Answer
Answer: b.Local governments only have the power that is specifically granted to them by states. Dillon's Rule affirms that a local government is granted very narrow authority. That it may engage in an activity only if it is specifically conferred by the state government.
The correct answer is B) Local governments only have the power that is specifically granted to them by states.
From the British gov’t perspective, why are these changes necessary? From the colonial perspective, why are these changes difficult to handle?
The Dillon Rule limits a local governing body’s ability to address local issues using local strategies exercised under its police power. As a result, a locality’s ability to address local issues is at the mercy of the General Assembly unless a means to address the issue has already been enabled. A locality’s governing body does not have broad ...
An attempt to reverse Dillon’s Rule for cities and certain counties by constitutional amendment failed in 1970. Judge Dillon’s 19th Century treatise lives today in contemporary Virginia jurisprudence. First followed in City of Winchester v.
While Virginia is considered one of the stricter Dillon rule states, the Brookings Institution study shows that 31 states operate under Dillon’s Rule while 10 states do not abide by it.
The rule itself is the result of Dillon’s distrust of city government. By the 1860s, cities had become not only inefficient, but corrupt. Graft, in the form of kickbacks, was rampant for many public works and public utility projects, including the railroads.
Understandably, Dillon did not trust local government and wrote in his book, "Commentaries on the Law of Municipal Corporations," (1911), the usefulness of our municipal corporation has been impaired by evils that are either inherent in them or that have generally accompanied their workings.
Virginia is a Dillon Rule state - as opposed to a Home Rule state - which means that its localities and governing bodies can only take action where they have been delegated authority to do so by the Virginia Assembly. Adopted in 1896 by the Virginia Supreme Court, the Virginia General Assembly has delegated broad authority to local governments ...