what is the natural course of government in a democracy according to tocqueville

by Alva Toy 5 min read

Was Tocqueville an aristocrat or a democracy?

Tocqueville on centralization as the natural form of government for democracies (1835) Found in Democracy in America: Historical-Critical Edition, vol. 1. Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-1859) believed that the natural form of government for a democratic people was one which was centralized, uniform and strong: I have shown that equality suggested to men the thought of a …

What does Tocqueville mean by equality of conditions?

According to Tocqueville, the power of the majority arises from the fact that in a democracy every individual is, politically, the equal of every other individual. In this situation, the greatest power will always be the largest number of individuals who combine …

What is Tocqueville’s dike against the majority?

According to Tocqueville, a democratic government works for the interests and well-being of the people 5. Following this principle, US Democracy is deteriorating. Furthermore, America’s love for equality is and will continue to create a situation whereby the oppressed stand up and fight for social justice 6 .

What did de Tocqueville say about the middle class?

Aug 19, 2021 · In the 1830s, French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville spent several months touring the United States. He used the notes of his observations to write the classic book, '''Democracy in …

What does Tocqueville say about democracy?

As “Democracy in America” revealed, Tocqueville believed that equality was the great political and social idea of his era, and he thought that the United States offered the most advanced example of equality in action.Nov 9, 2009

What type of government had Tocqueville?

Alexis de Tocqueville was born during the reign of Napoleon, and he was raised in the aristocratic monarchy that followed Napoleon until 1830.

What is Tocqueville's main thesis?

The core of Tocqueville's American thesis is the singular combination of the spirit of religion and the spirit of liberty characteristic of the Puritan experiment in America, together with his dual claim that this fact both constitutes the proper starting point for understanding “American civilization” and provides “ ...

What did de Tocqueville believe about the future of democracy?

The Future of Democracy De Tocqueville, however, saw another even more disturbing threat to American democracy. He feared that American citizens would become so satisfied with being equal to one another that they would abandon their deep interest and involvement in self-government.

Is it Tocqueville or de Tocqueville?

Alexis de TocquevilleBornAlexis Charles Henri Clérel de Tocqueville29 July 1805 Paris, FranceDied16 April 1859 (aged 53) Cannes, FranceResting placeTocqueville, ManchePolitical partyMovement Party (1839–1848) Party of Order (1848–1851)39 more rows

Would you identify Tocqueville as a proponent of socialism or a democracy quizlet?

He was privately tutored and he studied law in Paris. Was Tocqueville a supporter of democratic revolutions? Yes. He supported both the French and American revolution.

Is Tocqueville opposed to democracy?

Tocqueville speculates on the future of democracy in the United States, discussing possible threats to democracy and possible dangers of democracy. These include his belief that democracy has a tendency to degenerate into "soft despotism" as well as the risk of developing a tyranny of the majority.

What are the 5 values identified by Alexis de Tocqueville?

US. 22A Discuss Alexis de Tocqueville's five values crucial to America's success as a constitutional republic: liberty, egalitarianism, individualism, populism, and laissez-faire. US. 22B Describe how the American values identified by Alexis de Tocqueville are different and unique from those of other nations.

What is the thesis or the main idea of the text Democracy in America?

Tocqueville's main purpose in writing Democracy in America was to analyze the functioning of political society and the various forms of political associations, although he also had some reflections on civil society as well as the relations between political and civil society.Apr 19, 2019

What did Alexis de Tocqueville observe?

He observed that voluntary giving, which in Europe was accomplished through religious charity and State support, took the form of mutual assistance in America. Americans banded together to build hospitals, prisons, churches and schools.

Which of the following did de Tocqueville point out in his Democracy in America quizlet?

What was the one thing he found in America? Equality ("of conditions"). For us, there's no such thing as enough equality - it is inherent to the character of democratic peoples.

Which best describes Alexis de Tocqueville?

"Which best describes Alexis de Tocqueville? "He was a French historian and political scientist who championed "uniquely American" values such as egalitarianism."

Who is Alexis de Tocqueville?

Part of A Long Tradition. Alexis de Tocqueville is part of a long tradition of well-educated Europeans who traveled to America and published books or diaries about their experiences in the “new” world. Unlike most of the others, however, the book Tocqueville wrote has proved over the years to be a lasting source of information ...

How many volumes are there in Democracy in America?

Democracy in America is a large book in two volumes (published five years apart, in 1835 and 1840). Volume One describes and analyzes American conditions and political institutions, while Volume Two examines the effect of American democracy on what we would call culture (literature, economics, the family, religion, etc.).

What is the power of the majority?

According to Tocqueville, the power of the majority arises from the fact that in a democracy every individual is , politically, the equal of every other individual. In this situation, the greatest power will always be the largest number of individuals who combine their strength to act together: normally, a majority.

Who wrote the book Democracy in America?

Wikimedia Commons. Democracy in America by Alexis de Tocqueville is universally regarded as one of the most influential books ever written about America. While historians have viewed Democracy as a rich source about the age of Andrew Jackson, Tocqueville was more of a political thinker than a historian. In the introduction to Democracy, he states: ...

Who was the French aristocrat who visited the United States in 1831?

In 1831 an ambitious and unusually perceptive twenty-five-year-old French aristocrat visited the United States. Alexis de Tocqueville ’s official purpose was to study the American penal system, but his real interest was America herself.

What did De Tocqueville write about?

Upon returning to France, de Tocqueville published his studies on American society. It was not that all Americans were materially equal, but from rich to poor, the social positions of free, white Americans were not enforced by society, institutions, or luck of birth, as they were in Europe.

Who is Alexis de Tocqueville?

Lesson Transcript. In this lesson, we'll learn about Alexis de Tocqueville, a Frenchman who wrote a book about his observations of American society during the Jackson era.

When was Democracy in America published?

Upon returning to France, de Tocqueville published Democracy in America in 1835, and it has become a classic of history, cultural studies, and American studies.

What was Europe like in the 1830s?

In the 1830s, Europe was reeling from war, revolution, and a decaying aristocracy. The old world was hampered by old ideas, and many Europeans did not hesitate to criticize their societies and cultures and look abroad for better models of government.

Did De Tocqueville miss the poor?

Given our knowledge of Jacksonian America, it is clear that de Tocqueville and Beaumont missed several realities, including the large number of urban poor. Based on his writings, we also know that he had little contact with the lower classes of American society, moving instead among the more wealthy and connected elites. This did not mean he took no notice of poverty, but it most certainly colored his more rosy experiences and ruminations on American life.

Why was Tocqueville sent to America?

Image. Tocqueville was sent by the French government to America in 1831 in order to inspect the prison systems, but he used his nine-month trip as an occasion to study all aspects of American life. As a result of this careful study he published the first volume of Democracy in America in 1835, and the second five years later, in 1840.

What is the danger of Tocqueville?

One of the principal dangers is what he calls the “tyranny of the majority,” which refers to the tendency of the majority to override, or suppress, the interests and opinions of the minority.

What is Tocqueville's point of departure?

Tocqueville is generally more optimistic about the prospects of democracy in America as opposed to democracy in post-revolutionary France. This is largely due to American democracy’s point of departure: its Puritan origins. The Puritans combined two seemingly conflicting elements — the spirit of religion and the spirit of freedom. The spirit of religion safeguards morals by restricting freedom within relatively narrow bounds: true liberty, which is distinguished from the license to do whatever one wants, is exhibited especially in self-government. Moral restraint is thus combined with a democratic notion of political freedom.

How many pages are there in Democracy in America?

Democracy in America, Tocqueville’s most famous book, is a two-volume work spanning some 700 pages and covering nearly every aspect of American social and political life: the arrival of the Puritans; American laws and political institutions; the country’s habits, morals, and religious opinions; even its arts and sciences.

What is the love of equality?

The love of equality can be seen in the incessant desire for equality of outcome rather than simply equality of opportunity. The progressive income tax is one example of the democratic love of equality seeking to level economic inequalities.

What is moral restraint?

Moral restraint is thus combined with a democratic notion of political freedom. This spirit of liberty, according to Tocqueville, is especially embodied in the New England township — a form of local government in which citizens of the town govern themselves by forming their own deliberative assembly.

Causes Tocqueville identifies which have maintained a democracy in America

Alexis de Tocqueville – Democracy in America, vol. 1#N#Chapter XVII – “Causes Which Tend to Maintain Democracy”#N#Write an analysis about the causes Tocqueville identifies which have maintained a#N#democracy in America. In your analysis, consider the following questions:#N#1. What are the causes Tocqueville identifies?#N#2.

The causes that Tocqueville identifies that maintained democracy in America

Tocqueville identifies three reasons that have sustained democracy among the American people. These three reasons include geographic location, manners, and legislation. The manners of the American people are one of the critical factors that have continued to maintain democracy in America.

What are the three main features that Tocqueville regarded as central to American democracy?

Three main features that Tocqueville regarded as central to American democracy are discussed: the importance of local government, the concept of “civil association,” and “the spirit of religion.”. The book is not simply a celebration of the democratic experience in America; Tocqueville is deeply worried about the potential of a democratic tyranny.

Is man a rational animal?

Man may be the rational animal, but reason is somehow unable to plumb or reason is unable to grasp the unfathomable depths of the universe. In one of his most famous statements, Pascal said, “A vapor,” a drop of water is enough to kill him, speaking of us, humans. “A drop of water is enough to kill us.

Part of A Long Tradition

Image
Alexis de Tocqueville is part of a long tradition of well-educated Europeans who traveled to America and published books or diaries about their experiences in the “new” world. Unlike most of the others, however, the book Tocqueville wrote has proved over the years to be a lasting source of information and insight into both A…
See more on edsitement.neh.gov

How to Teach Tocqueville’s Introduction

  • Use the following activities and worksheets to help students understand what specific developments and events in history contribute to the advancement of greater equality in society and which ones Tocqueville regarded as most important.
See more on edsitement.neh.gov

Activity 1. “Equality of Condition”

  • Have a student read out loud the first three paragraphs of the Introduction. Follow this with a brief discussion of this passage, beginning with the question, what is it about America that most impressed Tocqueville? This is of course something he calls the “equality of conditions.” Tocqueville does not say much about this here; he doesn’t even define it or tell us what it is. But …
See more on edsitement.neh.gov

Activity 2. “A Great Democratic Revolution Is Taking Place Among Us”

  • Tocqueville then shifts his attention to France (and more generally, to Europe) and announces that “a great democratic revolution is taking place among us.” The problem is that there is an important division of opinion in France about what this revolution means. Is it something new and accidental that can be stopped, or is it something deep and old, indeed, “the most permanent fac…
See more on edsitement.neh.gov

Activity 3. “Providential Fact” Or “Force of Nature”?

  • By this point, it should be clear to the students that of the two opinions about the “great democratic revolution” summarized in the fifth paragraph of the Introduction, Tocqueville himself adheres to the second one, namely that it is “irresistible because ... it seems the most continuous, the oldest, and the most permanent fact known in history.” The lesson could end here, but if ther…
See more on edsitement.neh.gov

Selected EDSITEment Websites