If you have ever taken an antibiotic, you likely know the drill: Finish the entire course of treatment, even if you are feeling better, or else you risk a relapse. Worse, by not finishing, you might contribute to the dangerous rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
If you have ever taken an antibiotic, you likely know the drill: Finish the entire course of treatment, even if you are feeling better, or else you risk a relapse. Worse, by not finishing, you might contribute to the dangerous rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
AS A pharmacist, Allan Wilson should know better if he is suggesting that antibiotic courses are too long. A number of factors will determine how long it takes even an effective antibiotic to eliminate an infection.
Antibiotics are vital to modern medicine but overuse has contributed to antibiotic resistance, now considered a global threat to human health. The World Health Organization still advises patients to “always complete the full prescription, even if you feel better," but there is no scientific evidence that supports the claim.
So that more germs don't build up a resistance to antibiotics, it's important that the drugs not be used unless they're needed. The current recommendation by the World Health Organization (WHO) is to "always complete the full prescription, even if you feel better, because stopping treatment early promotes the growth of drug-resistant bacteria.”
By cutting treatment short, you increase the chances of the existing bacteria mutating and becoming resistant, therefore making it harder to treat the next time around.
According to the World Health Organisation, stopping treatment early involves the risk of not getting all of the bacteria that made you unwell killed off. As we don’t know who can safely stop treatment early, making your own judgement could result in you falling ill again.
If you wind up with leftover antibiotics, don’t hang on to them . Discard unused antibiotics by returning them to the pharmacy or a community take-back program. Or mix the medication with an unpalatable substance such as coffee grounds or kitty litter, seal it in a bag, and throw it out with the household trash.
If you have been fever-free for 24 to 48 hours and are feeling significantly better, “it’s reasonable to call your doctor and ask if you can stop your antibiotic,” she says. And be reassured that “stopping short of a full course of antibiotics won’t worsen the problem of antibiotic resistance,” Peto says.
The idea that people need to take all their antibiotics, even after they’re feeling better, is based in part on outdated notions about what causes antibiotic resistance, says Lauri Hicks, D.O., a medical epidemiologist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and head of the agency’s Get Smart: Know When Antibiotics Work program.
Plus, the longer you take antibiotics, the more likely you are to wipe out the “good” bacteria in your intestines, Hicks says. That leaves you vulnerable to infection from the bacterium clostridium difficile, or C. diff, which can cause dangerous inflammation, abdominal cramping, and severe diarrhea, and can even be deadly.
Talk to Your Doctor About Antibiotics. About one-third of antibiotics prescribed in doctors’ offices are unnecessary, according to a recent report from the CDC. Doctors commonly prescribe these drugs for upper-respiratory illnesses such as bronchitis, colds, and the flu.
In those cases, it's usually important to finish all the medication prescribed for you. However, for less serious illnesses, such as pneumonia, a sinus infection, or a urinary tract infection, you may not need to finish, Hicks says.
According to Hicks, scientists have come to realize that the larger problem is that antibiotics affect not only the bacteria causing the infection but also the trillions of other bacteria that live in and on your body. “We have more bacteria in our body than human cells,” she says.
These include the fact that there are areas of the body where antibiotics do not achieve good penetration (e.g. the lungs and sinuses). The quantity of infective material that may have built up in the body, and from which re-infection may occur, must also be taken into account.
If the drug manufacturers know the antibiotic is effective in 48 hours then a recommended five-day treatment would keep everybody happy, including their shareholders. Allan Wilson, Pharmacist, Comrie, Perthshire. AS A pharmacist, Allan Wilson should know better if he is suggesting that antibiotic courses are too long.
THE danger to the individual is that the infection will recur, and will be more difficult to treat when it does. The danger to the rest of us is that the general population of the infecting bacterium will become more resistant to the antibiotic concerned.
This debate is meaningless in light of the fact that decision to go to a doctor was that of the patient and he/she decided to go because of the confidence in the doctor's ability. Once prescribed by the doctor, I strongly believe that one must complete the course as prescribed.
As the surviving bacteria reproduce, the resulting infection would not be treatable with the same antibiotic. If the infection is passed on to someone else, their infection will also be resistant to the antibiotic. Jim Lodge, London SE4.
Antibiotics will not cure viral infections. So, prescribing antibiotics without properly ascertaining the cause of infection is indeed an equally real danger.
Mary Ingham, Ramsgate, Kent. I think the danger of creating antibiotic-resistant bacteria is very real. Bacterial infections, before antibiotics, quite often proved to be fatal and by discontinuing a course of prescribed antibiotics, we run the risk of going back there.
They argue that it is not backed by evidence and should be replaced. Antibiotics are important for fighting off infections, but there is a growing global concern about the number of cases in which bacteria have become resistant to these medicines. So that more germs don't build up a resistance to antibiotics, it's important ...
The current recommendation by the World Health Organization (WHO) is to "always complete the full prescription, even if you feel better, because stopping treatment early promotes the growth of drug-resistant bacteria.”. But several experts in infectious diseases are urging policymakers, educators, and doctors to reconsider ...
They say that there is no evidence that stopping antibiotics early encourages antibiotic resistance -- and ...
In pneumonias that were acquired in the hospital, for example, randomized-controlled trial data indicates that short-term medication courses — for three to five days — is as effective as longer courses and were associated with lower rates of infection recurrence and antibiotic resistance.
In other words, if a child feels completely better after five or six days out of a 10-day course, it's safe to stop.
Take your antibiotic, all of it, doctors order. Five out of every six Americans are prescribed antibiotics each year, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
According to the report, an individual’s risk of resistant infection depends on how much of an antibiotic they've taken in the past, so reducing exposure with shorter courses of antibiotic treatment is associated with lowered risk of resistant infection. Patients are put an unnecessary risk from antibiotic resistance when treatment is given ...
Patients are put an unnecessary risk from antibiotic resistance when treatment is given for longer than necessary, not when it is stopped early, British researchers say. Shutterstock. "It very much is challenging the dogma that shorter courses of antibiotics are inferior.
Doctors are still figuring out what the appropriate length of treatment is, Schaffner said. Antibiotics are vital to modern medicine but overuse has contributed to antibiotic resistance, now considered a global threat to human health.
Worse, by not finishing, you might contribute to the dangerous rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria. The advice to always finish your antibiotics has long been considered medical dogma, and can be seen today on the websites of the World Health Organization, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and other leading health authorities.
The idea that stopping an antibiotic treatment early encourages antibiotic resistance is not supported by scientific evidence, he said. Moreover, having everyone finish their antibiotics all the time may actually be increasing antibiotic resistance worldwide, because it's the taking of antibiotics for longer than absolutely necessary ...
Boucher said she agrees with the BMJ authors' stance that "completing the course" merely for the sake of lowering the risk of antibacterial resistance is not based on solid scientific evidence. She added, however, that doctors don't often know when a shorter course of antibiotics is as effective as a longer one.