Gatsby's response to Nick's observation that you can't repeat the past is incredulity. He says, "Can't repeat the past? Why of course you can!" To him, it seems perfectly reasonable to expect that Daisy would be able to tell Tom that she never loved him, and pick up where she left off with him, Gatsby, five years ago.
Full Answer
He is trying to get Gatsby to understand her outlook, but Gatsby is still faithful to the dream that, to his way of thinking and valuing, is embodied by Daisy Fay. In Chapter Six, Nick tells Gatsby that you can't repeat the past. This is Gatsby's reply: “Can’t repeat the past?” he cried incredulously. “Why of course you can!”
Do you agree with Nick or with Gatsby? Most readers would agree with Nick that you can't repeat the past. That Gatsby believes he is able to repeat the past highlights his disconnect from reality.
Gatsby is confident that he will be able to repeat the past of when he and Daisy first met now that he has the money to attract her attention. His view is very simplistic and naïve.
If it were not possible to repeat the past, then Gatsby would lose his reason for being. This explains why he cries "incredulously" (unwilling to believe what Nick says).
“Can't repeat the past? Why, of course you can!” Jay Gatsby, the protagonist of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, said this to his friend Nick Carraway in order to convince both himself and Nick that he could recapture Daisy Buchanan, his former love.
In response to Nick Gatsby say's "can't repeat the past? Why of course you can!" This truly highlights his inability to accept the truth, being that Daisy has moved on and is married with a child. It is not only foolish, it is delusional to think that you can turn back time.
When Nick cautions Gatsby that "You can't repeat the past," Gatsby idealistically answers "Why of course you can!" words that strike Nick soundly because of their "appalling sentimentality," which both delights and disgusts him.
“You can't repeat the past.” “Can't repeat the past?” he cried incredulously. “Why of course you can!” He looked around him wildly, as if the past were lurking here in the shadow of his house, just out of reach of his hand.
When Nick told Gatsby, "You can't repeat the past," Gatsby replied, "Why of course you can!" Do you agree with Nick or Gatsby? I believe that you can do your best to duplicate something from the past, but it will not be exactly as it was before.
To Nick's statement that "you can't repeat the past" Gatsby replies incredulously, "Can't repeat the past? Why of course you can!" Gatsby is confident that he will be able to repeat the past of when he and Daisy first met now that he has the money to attract her attention. His view is very simplistic and naive.
Simply, you can't repeat the past because you are not the same person you were in the past. As you grow and get older, your experiences start forming who you are and the decisions you make. My strong belief is that it's OK to look back as long as you continue to move on.
Nick know that you can't and shouldn't repeat the past, but Gatsby thinks he can just erase the last five years and start over again. His opinion is unrealistic because it's been five years and both of them have changed.
LITERATURE. The theme of The Great Gatsby is that past cannot be repeated and everybody has to move forward in life. The author of the book F. Scott Fitzgerald was a popular writer in the 1920s and by using plot, style, figurative language, character, and setting he is able to develop the theme.
What does Gatsby tell Nick about his past? Is it true? He tells about the relationship he and Daisy had, the actual time spent together and how he had to go off to war, and Daisy was supposed to wait for him to return.
Traveling with Cody to the Barbary Coast and the West Indies, Gatsby fell in love with wealth and luxury. Cody was a heavy drinker, and one of Gatsby's jobs was to look after him during his drunken binges. This gave Gatsby a healthy respect for the dangers of alcohol and convinced him not to become a drinker himself.
In chapter seven, Tom reveals that he has discovered Gatsby's past of illegal alcohol sales.
Remember that he has dedicated his life to winning back Daisy Buchanan, the girl he loved and wanted to marry before being sent off to fight in the war.
If it were not possible to repeat the past, then Gatsby would lose his reason for being. This explains why he cries "incredulously" (unwilling to believe what Nick says). He simply cannot accept that repeating the past is not possible. If this were true, all of his hopes and dreams would be shattered in an instant.
Nick tries to both comfort Gatsby and deliver a reality check by telling him that he shouldn't expect too much of Daisy and that he "can't repeat the past." Gatsby is incredulous when he replies "Can't repeat the past? Why of course you can!"
Gatsby is confident that he repeat the past when he and Daisy first met. This time around, however, she will be his because he now has enough money. His simplistic view reveals how completely he has skewed reality in his desperation to have the woman of his dreams.
Following one of Gatsby 's summer parties, Gatsby complains that Daisy did not enjoy herself and tells Nick that it is hard to make Daisy "understand.". Nick Carraway mentions that Gatsby wanted nothing less of Daisy than for her to tell Tom that she never loved him and get a divorce.
Since Daisy married Tom, Gatsby has devoted every ounce of his energy and all of his resources to become as rich as possible so that he can grab Daisy's attention and pick up where they left off all those years ago.
Nick has the objectivity to see that Daisy is comfortable with the wealth, security, and social position that Tom Buchanan provides, even though he is unfaithful. He is trying to get Gatsby to understand her outlook, but Gatsby is still faithful to the dream that, to his way of thinking and valuing, is embodied by Daisy Fay.
“You can’t repeat the past,” says Nick Carraway to Jay Gatsby. This quote belongs in Chapter 6 of Francis Scott Fitzgerald’s famous novel, “The Great Gatsby.” To which Gatsby replies, “Can’t repeat the past? Why, of course, you can!” This conversation gives a hint about Gatsby’s intention to return Daisy Buchanan, his past love.
But her bonds with her husband are quite strong. At the same time, she knows he is cheating with Myrtle Wilson.
The plot tells the story of young Americans living in the West Egg and East Egg of upper-class Long Island. Fitzgerald masterfully depicts the glamorous and roaring twenties, with their thirst for life and hedonistic pleasures. The main plotline of the novel tells the readers about a love story. A mysterious millionaire Jay Gatsby tries to win back a married young lady Daisy Buchanan. Gatsby lives in a massive palace on the banks of the river and throws fancy parties there to impress Daisy. But her bonds with her husband are quite strong. At the same time, she knows he is cheating with Myrtle Wilson. By the way, there is an unexpected turn of events. At the end of the story, Daisy hits Myrtle, who doesn’t survive in a car accident.
At the same time, she knows he is cheating with Myrtle Wilson. By the way, there is an unexpected turn of events. At the end of the story, Daisy hits Myrtle, who doesn’t survive in a car accident. The story is told by Nick Carraway, who meets Gatsby upon arriving in New York.