how do you prove holder in due course cases

One of the requirements for a given holder to be deemed a holder in due course is for he or she to have taken the negotiable instrument in question for value, instead of as a gift or otherwise without making equal compensation to the party from which the holder received the negotiable instrument.

Full Answer

What is a holder in due course?

There are five different methods in which the holder in due course can accept the document as a source of value: The holder in due course fulfilled a promise after accepting the instrument. The holder can also accept the instrument through means of a lien through a court ruling or bankruptcy sale.

Is any kind checks cashed a holder in due course?

Apr 03, 2015 · Taking for Value. One of the requirements for a given holder to be deemed a holder in due course is for he or she to have taken the negotiable instrument in question for value, instead of as a gift or otherwise without making equal compensation to the party from which the holder received the negotiable instrument.

How do I become a holder in due course (HDC)?

Aug 09, 2016 · A Holder in Due Course can be defined as a holder who takes a negotiable instrument in good faith, without noticing that such instrument has been dishonored or that there is a hiden fraudulent issue behind it. In this particular case, I don’t think that Any Kind Checks Cashed, Inc. should be considered as a Holder in Due Course.

What does “in due course” mean?

A holder is a holder in due course (HDC) if he takes the instrument without reason to question its authenticity on account of obvious facial irregularities, for value, in good faith, and without notice that it is overdue or has been dishonored, or that it contains a forgery or alteration, or that that any person has any defense against it or claim to it.

What are the requisites to be considered a holder in due course?

(1) A holder in due course is a holder who takes the instrument (a) for value; and (b) in good faith; and (c) without notice that it is overdue or has been dishonored or of any defense against or claim to it on the part of any person. (2) A payee may be a holder in due course.

What are the three 3 elements needed for a person to be considered a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument?

To become a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument, a party must first qualify as a “holder” of the instrument. This means that the person must have possession of the instrument, and the instrument must be payable to that person or payable to bearer.

How can you determine if the holder of an instrument is a holder in due course?

Requirements for Being a Holder in Due CourseBe a holder of a negotiable instrument;Have taken it: a) for value, b) in good faith, c) without notice. (1) that it is overdue or. ... Have no reason to question its authenticity on account of apparent evidence of forgery, alteration, irregularity or incompleteness.

Who is not considered a holder in due course?

If one party accepts the instrument but does not complete their end of the deal, they are not the true holder of the item. There are two exceptions to this executory promise rule: If the instrument is given in exchange for a negotiable item.

What is a holder in due course?

Another requirement for being considered a holder in due course under commercial law is that the holder must have taken the negotiable instrument in good faith. This is one of the more important requirements for being considered a holder in due course, not in the sense of legality, but in the sense of the intent of HDC doctrine.

What is the requirement for a holder in due course?

A further requirement for gaining status as a holder in due course is that the current holder must have taken the negotiable instrument without notice as to any of the myriad forms of wrongdoing or warning that might have clued that holder in to the fact that the negotiable instrument was not fully supported or was inauthentic.

What is the second way to take for value?

The second way to take for value is to obtain a security interest or other lien in the negotiable instrument without having obtained that lien through a judicial proceeding such as a bankruptcy sale. The third way to take for value is ...

What is the requirement for a given holder to be deemed a holder in due course?

One of the requirements for a given holder to be deemed a holder in due course is for he or she to have taken the negotiable instrument in question for value, instead of as a gift or otherwise without making equal compensation to the party from which the holder received the negotiable instrument.

What is the purpose of the holder in due course doctrine?

The holder in due course (HDC) doctrine is designed to protect holders from culpability in situations where they performed no wrongdoing, but might be affected by another party’s attempt at a defense because they hold the negotiable instruments being contested. But HDC doctrine has been violated a number of times, as it has been turned to fraudulent purposes.

Why is being a holder in due course important?

Because being a holder in due course offers a significant amount of protection from the actions of other parties in the chain of negotiations for a given negotiable instrument, there are a number of requirements which must be fulfilled in order for a party to qualify as a holder in due course. These requirements are mostly there so as to prevent the status of being a holder in due course from being overly abused by parties seeking to perpetrate fraud and protect themselves from any lawsuits or defenses.

When is a transaction considered taking for value?

The first way is if the current holder fulfills the promise he or she made when he or she obtained the negotiable instrument. If a negotiable instrument is exchanged for some kind of promised service, then the transaction is not considered to be “taking for value” until such a time as the promise is fulfilled.

What is a holder in due course?

A holder is a holder in due course (HDC) if he takes the instrument without reason to question its authenticity on account of obvious facial irregularities, for value, in good faith, and without notice that it is overdue or has been dishonored, or that it contains a forgery or alteration, or that that any person has any defense against it or claim to it. The HDC takes the paper free of most defenses; an ordinary holder takes the paper as an assignee, acquiring only the rights of the assignor.

Why is the holder in due course important?

The holder-in-due-course doctrine is important because it allows the holder of a negotiable instrument to take the paper free from most claims and defenses against it. Without the doctrine, such a holder would be a mere transferee. The UCC provides that to be an HDC, a person must be a holder of paper that is not suspiciously irregular, and she must take it in good faith, for value, and without notice of anything that a reasonable person would recognize as tainting the instrument. A payee may be an HDC but usually would not be (because he would know of problems with it). The shelter rule says that a transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights her transferor had, so a person can have the rights of an HDC without satisfying the requirements of an HDC (provided she does not engage in any fraud or illegality related to the transaction).

What is the shelter rule for holder in due course?

The shelter rule#N#Under Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code, the transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights his or her transferor had.#N#provides that the transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights that the transferor had. Thus a person who does not himself qualify as an HDC can still acquire that status if some previous holder (someone “upstream”) was an HDC.

Why did Carter argue that its motion for summary judgment should have been granted?

Carter argues that its motion for summary judgment should have been granted because, as a holder in due course, it has the right to recover on the checks from the drawer, Omni.

Is HDC subject to personal defenses?

An HDC in a nonconsumer transaction is not subject to personal defenses, but he is subject to the so-called real defenses#N#In negotiable-instrument law, defenses that are good against a holder in due course.#N#(or “universal defenses”)—they are good against an HDC.

Is honesty in fact subjectively tested?

“Honesty in fact” is subjectively tested. Suppose Lorna Love had given Rackets, Inc., a promissory note for the tennis rackets. Knowing that it intended to deliver defective tennis rackets and that Love is likely to protest as soon as the shipment arrives, Rackets offers a deep discount on the note to its fleet mechanic: instead of the $1,000 face value of the note, Rackets will give it to him in payment of an outstanding bill of $400. The mechanic, being naive in commercial dealings, has no suspicion from the large discount that Rackets might be committing fraud. He has acted in good faith under the UCC test. That is not to say that no set of circumstances will ever exist to warrant a finding that there was a lack of good faith.

Can a purchaser with knowledge become an HDC?

It obviously would be unjust to permit a holder to enforce an instrument that he knew—when he acquired it—was defective, was subject to claims or defenses, or had been dishonored. A purchaser with knowledge cannot become an HDC. But proving knowledge is difficult, so the UCC at Section 3-302 (2) lists several types of notice that presumptively defeat any entitlement to status as HDC. Notice is not limited to receipt of an explicit statement; it includes an inference that a person should have made from the circumstances. The explicit things that give a person notice include those that follow.

Why is the holder in due course important?

The holder-in-due-course doctrine is important because it allows the holder of a negotiable instrument to take the paper free from most claims and defenses against it. Without the doctrine, such a holder would be a mere transferee. The UCC provides that to be an HDC, a person must be a holder of paper that is not suspiciously irregular, and she must take it in good faith, for value, and without notice of anything that a reasonable person would recognize as tainting the instrument. A payee may be an HDC but usually would not be (because he would know of problems with it). The shelter rule says that a transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights her transferor had, so a person can have the rights of an HDC without satisfying the requirements of an HDC (provided she does not engage in any fraud or illegality related to the transaction).

What is the shelter rule for holder in due course?

The shelter rule#N#Under Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code, the transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights his or her transferor had.#N#provides that the transferee of an instrument acquires the same rights that the transferor had. Thus a person who does not himself qualify as an HDC can still acquire that status if some previous holder (someone “upstream”) was an HDC.

Can a purchaser with knowledge become an HDC?

It obviously would be unjust to permit a holder to enforce an instrument that he knew—when he acquired it—was defective, was subject to claims or defenses, or had been dishonored. A purchaser with knowledge cannot become an HDC. But proving knowledge is difficult, so the UCC at Section 3-302 (2) lists several types of notice that presumptively defeat any entitlement to status as HDC. Notice is not limited to receipt of an explicit statement; it includes an inference that a person should have made from the circumstances. The explicit things that give a person notice include those that follow.

Is buying an instrument at a discount unreasonable?

Whether reasonable commercial standards were observed in the dealings is objectively tested, but buying an instrument at a discount—as was done in the tennis rackets example—is not commercially unreasonable, necessarily.

Is honesty in fact subjectively tested?

“Honesty in fact” is subjectively tested. Suppose Lorna Love had given Rackets, Inc., a promissory note for the tennis rackets. Knowing that it intended to deliver defective tennis rackets and that Love is likely to protest as soon as the shipment arrives, Rackets offers a deep discount on the note to its fleet mechanic: instead of the $1,000 face value of the note, Rackets will give it to him in payment of an outstanding bill of $400. The mechanic, being naive in commercial dealings, has no suspicion from the large discount that Rackets might be committing fraud. He has acted in good faith under the UCC test. That is not to say that no set of circumstances will ever exist to warrant a finding that there was a lack of good faith.

Is a person who has notice that an instrument is overdue an HDC?

The UCC provides generally that a person who has notice that an instrument is overdue cannot be an HDC. What constitutes notice? When an inspection of the instrument itself would show that it was due before the purchaser acquired it, notice is presumed. A transferee to whom a promissory note due April 23 is negotiated on April 24 has notice that it was overdue and consequently is not an HDC. Not all paper contains a due date for the entire amount, and demand paper has no due date at all. In Sections 3-302 (a) (2) and 3-304, the UCC sets out specific rules dictating what is overdue paper.

What are the requirements for a holder of an instrument to become a holder in due course?

What are the requirements for a holder of an instrument to become a holder in due course? To qualify as a HDC, the holder of the commercial paper must meet the following requirements: Value - The holder must take the instrument for value. This means that the holder must provide money or goods for the instrument.

Can a transferor manipulate the law?

It is easy to imagine any number of schemes in which a transferor would try to manipulate the law by transferring an instrument to a holder with a greater right to repayment. Unaware of Defenses - The holder cannot have notice that there is a valid defense to enforcement of the instrument.