DIFFERENCE BETWEEN JUSTIFICATION AND EXCUSE DEFENSE 2 Justification and excuse defenses share some similarity in that both types of defenses admit to the defendant committing the act. However, in a criminal case, these two defenses are different. A justified action is not criminal, whereas an excused defendant has committed a crime but is not punishable (Berman …
· Selected Answer: An excuse is a reason for breaking a principle, while the justification provides an argument that violating some moral principle is the right course of action. Correct Answer: An excuse is a reason for breaking a principle, while the justification provides an argument that violating some moral
Excuses and Justifications • Excuses describe instances in which one is exempted from the law that would ordinarily be applicable. • They apply to the person and circumstances, not the act. • …
· Selected Answer : Excuses are the thoughts of right and wrong , while justifications are the moral principles in a given situation . Correct Answer : An excuse is a …
explanations are similar to justifications or excuses but are not labelled as
If Ann is excused, she may be regarded as wholly or partly. free of blame, but she will have demonstrated weakness or some defect. Because the moral evaluation of a justified actor differs from the moral. evaluation of an excused actor, deciding whether Ann is justified or excused is.
analogue of a moral justification or excuse is typically relieved of liability. Because of the injury to Ben, it is likely that Ann will be prosecuted for. assault, which is defined as "purposely, knowingly, or recklessly causing. bodily injury to another.".
only refer to the second kind of explanation-that is, they concede the. presence of the basic elements but deny liability on independent grounds. If.
future violation of duty may justify a present violation of another duty. For. them, Maude's adultery is wrongful, although her self-awareness, if accurate, may give her some kind of excuse or partial justification. Each of these examples shows how the labels ofjustification and excuse tie.
As J.L. Austin noted in A Plea for Excuses, "[when] I have broken your dish...