according to kant, why would it be immoral to make a false promise? course hero

by Lysanne Haley Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago 5 min read

According to him, the implementation of a false promise is only resulted due to the fear of the consequence in the present moment. He deliberates on the thought behind the incidence of making a promise without the intention of keeping it and concludes that it is unwise to do so.

Full Answer

What are the consequences of making a false promise?

Sep 08, 2012 · Answer by Martin Jenkins. In his Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morality [1785], Immanuel Kant introduces and elaborates the morality of the Categorical Imperative. He provides various examples such as the one concerning Promising. A person is in financial difficulty and needs money. S/he hopes to acquire the money by borrowing it on the ...

What is the motive for keeping a promise?

Dec 27, 2018 · According to Kant, why would it be immoral to make a false promise? A. It would only be immoral only if it goes against the moral values of society B. It cannot become a universal law because it would be self-defeating C. It goes against the Ten Commandments 12. Which of the following claims is made by Paul Camenisch in his essay On getting to the

What is Immanuel Kant’s deontological ethics?

Jan 04, 2019 · Kant discusses the actions of making a false promise. According to him, the implementation of a false promise is only resulted due to the fear of the consequence in the present moment. He deliberates on the thought behind the incidence of making a promise without the intention of keeping it and concludes that it is unwise to do so.

What are moral actions according to Kant?

This paper discusses why breaking a promise or lying is considered to be immoral according to Kant’s theory. According to Kant, some actions like lying or making false promises are wrong for any person, in any society and at any time because according to the universal law they are considered to be wrong A person should always act on the ...

What is immoral according to Kant?

Kant considered self-improvement and preservation to be an undebatable obligation that is placed on everyone. Therefore, unproductivity, suicide, or any form of self-destruction is inherently immoral.

Why is Kant lying immoral?

To be human, said Kant, is to have the rational power of free choice; to be ethical, he continued, is to respect that power in oneself and others. Lies are morally wrong, then, for two reasons. First, lying corrupts the most important quality of my being human: my ability to make free, rational choices.

Why is breaking a promise or lying immoral?

Even ethical debates over lying, breaking promises, cheating, and stealing have multiple sides to them. All of these are generally seen as immoral because they decrease trust, weaken social bonds, and disrespect the natural rights of others.Nov 9, 2021

Why is it wrong to lie?

Lying is bad because a generally truthful world is a good thing: lying diminishes trust between human beings: if people generally didn't tell the truth, life would become very difficult, as nobody could be trusted and nothing you heard or read could be trusted - you would have to find everything out for yourself.

What did Kant believe about truth?

According to Kant, truth is a predicate of whole judgments, and not a predicate of the representational proper parts of judgments, i.e., intuitions/non-conceptual cognitions and concepts (A293/B350).Jul 28, 2004

What would Kant say about breaking a promise?

Kant famously claimed that universalizing the maxim of false promising leads to a contradiction: if everyone accepted the maxim behind false promising, the trust in promises would completely disappear and the institution of promising would break down.

Why is breaking a promise wrong?

It not only disappoints the person we've promised, but it also erodes bits of our self-esteem, too. Brain research shows that breaking promises actually registers in our brain activity, showing up as emotional conflict for the promise breaker as a result of suppressing their honesty.Apr 12, 2016

What does Kant say about keeping a promise?

As we shall argue, Kant believed that promises are binding if they are accepted, because by accept- ing a promise or offer, the offeree acquired something that became his own, namely, the offeror's choice to perform a certain act.

What does Kant say about false promises?

Kant discusses the actions of making a false promise. According to him, the implementation of a false promise is only resulted due to the fear of the consequence in the present moment. He deliberates on the thought behind the incidence of making a promise without the intention of keeping it and concludes that it is unwise to do so. ...

What is Kant's argument?

Immanuel Kant’s argument is reductionist, as it repudiates the presence of dissimilar events or occasions. For instance, one may make a false promise not to hurt an individual, such as promising a patient that everything will be okay, to give them the necessary hope that can augment their healing process.

What is Immanuel Kant known for?

Immanuel Kant is vastly known for his deontological ethics which discuss the morality of an action in regards to its intention. Kant discusses the actions of making a false promise. According to him, the implementation of a false promise is only resulted due to the fear of the consequence in the present moment.

What is Kant's contribution to ethics?

Despite the presence of weaknesses in his theory, Kant’s contribution to ethics has opened up a new era in the ethical arena of Philosophy. Leave a Thoughtful Comment.

What is Kant's deontological ethics?

As Immanuel Kant’s deontological ethics urge individuals to focus on duty rather than outcome, it is stated that if every individual act with good intentions, the consequences of those actions would be good naturally. Considering the example of false promises, if all individuals are truthful, the sanctity of the act will benefit society as a whole.

What does Kant say about morals?

Kant claims that an action has moral worth only if it is done for the sake of duty. True or False. True. In Kant's terminology, a maxim is: a principle on which one acts. It is a duty to secure one's own happiness, according to Kant. True or False.

What is a maxim in Kant's philosophy?

In Kant's terminology, a maxim is: a principle on which one acts. It is a duty to secure one's own happiness, according to Kant. True or False. True. According to Kant, the only thing that is good without qualification is: a good will.

What is Kant's metaphysics?

Kant claims that the metaphysics of morals is: purely rational. According to Kant, the basis of morality is the concept of: freedom. Kant claims that moral obligations are hypothetical imperatives. True or False. False. Kant claims that the dictates of morality are: categorical imperatives.

What is the categorical imperative?

categorical imperatives. Kant claims that an action is morally good only if: both a and b. According to the humanity formulation of the categorical imperative, we should always act: so as to treat humanity as an end in itself. According to Kant, morality requires us to: